Big Unit More Dominant Than Clemens?
I'm not going to dispute that Roger Clemens has had a more celebrated, illustrious career. But with both pitchers dueling to finish number two on the all time strikeout list, is it conceivable to say that Randy Johnson has been the more dominant pitcher over the course of his career?
In almost 1000 less innings, Randy Johnson has just 12 less K's than Clemens. Roger has never had a season with 300 strikeouts, while Johnson has had 6. The Big Unit strikes out 2 more men per 9 innings and has thrown a perfect game in his career.
The rest is up for debate. Both players have an almost identical ERA, opp. batting average, opp. on-base %, opp. slugging, and winning %, and both have had a 20-strikeout game. Clemens has amassed more wins and more Cy Young awards, though he did have a 4-year head start. But consider Roger's 2004 Cy Young: Randy Johnson had more IP, K's, and a lower ERA, but lost the Cy for being on a losing team. If Randy gets the Cy that year, then he has the same # of Cy Youngs (6) while playing in 135 less games with equal strikeouts. Not bad for someone with a mullet.





